Think Like a Man

Think Like a Man“There is no truer statement: men are simple.”  So begins the first chapter of Steve Harvey’s Act Like a Lady, Think Like a Man.  Men are driven by “who they are, what they do, and how much they make,” according to Harvey, and will not put a relationship first until they’re first satisfied with all three.  Women need to understand this and stop reading books by women who don’t and whose solution is to suggest that men need to be more like women.  That’s a dead end.  Men’s love isn’t like women’s love.  Men will profess their love for you (if they’re really serious), they’ll provide, they’ll protect.  In return women need to support their men, be loyal, and not be stingy with “The Cookie.”  It’s like the sexual revolution, feminism, and perhaps modernity itself never happened, except that women—now too free with The Cookie and believing that men really could act more like women—are now at a disadvantage in the war of the sexes.  Harvey proposes to give away mens’ battle plans (the traitor!).  The main counter-strategy: women, you can outflank men by becoming ladies again—or at least pretending to.  The book is old-fashioned and ultra traditional to the core.

Are men really that simple?  The “who they are” part is vague enough to allow for some subtlety to creep in, but much of my experience confirms what Harvey says.  I once belonged to a “marriage enrichment” group, but without our wives it was a struggle for us men to talk about anything but our jobs.  And sports.  One of the men—in what I see now as an act of incredible social bravery—quit the group, admitting that he felt inferior, job-wise, to the rest of us.  I belonged to another men’s group formed after a religious retreat.  Almost the same result.  I wonder how much men have ever changed.

Though the movie Think Like a Man is little more than a two-hour commercial for Act Like a Lady, Think Like a Man, I found it surprisingly enjoyable, perhaps because it rang true to my experience of being with men trying to be more modern, more feminine, less cave-mannish, or at least careerist.  Six guys meet to play basketball three times a week, and their aggressive, but natural, jovial friendship made a totally predictable movie pleasant.  Everything works out with cloying neatness: the “Player” stops playing, the “Mama’s Boy” escapes, the “Non-Committer” commits, the “Dreamer” gets to keep dreaming when his dream-killing girl friend becomes supportive and loyal.  (She always gave him cookies.) Even the loud-mouthed one going through a divorce finally admits the emptiness of the swinging single life and goes back home.

I dedicated one of my recent books, Black Writing from Chicago, to the great poet and community activist Haki Madhubuti, and used excerpts from his book Black Men: Obsolete, Single, Dangerous?  In the chapter titled “Not Allowed to Be Lovers,” he says that, “Sound and loving relationships are the core of a sane, happy and fruitful life,” but—as the chapter title  suggests—black men and women aren’t “allowed” to be this.  Madhubuti says, essentially, that black men are trying to model themselves after white men and white definitions of success and the virtual impossibility of that working out in a still-deeply racist society results in frustrations that poison relationships with “the most gross forms of competition, decadent individualism and sexual exploitation.”  It’s a deeper, more sociological perspective than Steve Harvey’s, but a lot of the outcomes are the same, and these relationship failures are one of the major factors leading black men towards obsolescence, singleness, and being inextricably associated with danger.

In Think Like a Man there are two white guys in the group, though one of them fancies himself at least culturally black.  Also, his significant other is black.  The other white is stereotypically big and white, but he’s the only one who seems to have it together relationally.  He seems happily married.  If he promises to be home to cook or watch the kids that’s what he does, and no amount of ball-and-chain man-kidding phases him.  He may represent a subconscious suggestion that white relationships are better, though we never actually see his wife, the movie totally erasing her.  Though Steve Harvey, black and extraordinarily popular with American blacks, may not mean this at all, he may still be taking aim  primarily at black men and the black women they fool.

The focus on black women needing to be more lady-like, plus the fact that the other white man’s black girlfriend is bigger than he is, and the loud mouth’s black wife is way bigger than he is (she drags him away by his shirt collar near the film’s end) could suggest that black men still have huge power issues when it comes to black women, who have more often than not been more successful at navigating white society than they have.  The movie just hints at these things.  It’s tag line is, “Let the mind games begin,” and it never really gets beyond this pop-psychology level, maintaining its entertaining fluffiness to the saccharine end, probably as it should.  But these relational troubles aren’t just mind games.  They arise from social structures and from an American history and culture deeply stained by what many have called our country’s great, original sin.  Men may be simple on some levels, but, whether man or woman, race ties every American’s hands and tongue and psyche into to unbelievably complicated knots.

(2012, Dir. Tim Story, 122m, PG-13.  I say 2.5 stars.)

*** See a list of other reviews, and go to the Teaching Diversity main page.

Posted in Diversity & Multiculturalism, Reviews & Commentary | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

With Liberty and Justice for All

Stephanie Lulay’s story below features the Hasan family, one of the “graduates” of Bryan House, an organization founded by Rick and Desiree Guzman and focused on breaking poverty cycles for refugee families.  The Hasan’s were also featured on an NBC news report.  As Bryan House grew and extended its programs to all the working poor, it became part of a larger organization, Emmanuel House.  In 2016 Emmanuel House was named one of the “Top 100 Most Innovative” social change organizations in the world. 

 

—By STEPHANIE LULAY, Sunday, July 3, 2011

THIS FOURTH OF JULY WEEKEND, WE SHARE STORIES OF PEOPLE WHO HAVE FLED THEIR HOMELANDS TO FIND REFUGE IN NORTHERN ILLINOIS

In post-2003 Baghdad, Imaad Hasan’s son’s name, Omar, wasn’t just a name anymore.  It was a target.

With liberty and justice for all

The Hasans in front of their Aurora home, purchased after a stay at Bryan House

“The militia tried to kidnap me and Omar several times,” Imaad said.  “We would move and then it would happen again.”

The biggest reason the family was targeted?  Religious differences.  The Hasans were Sunni, and the militia, Shiite.

The Shiite’s retribution for young Omar is linked to a division within Islam that stems from events some 1,300 yeasrs ago:  As a successor of Muhammad, Omar Bin al-Khattab is one of the most revered figures in Sunni history, but Shiites consider him illegitimate.

When Omar was 11 years old, masked men tried to kidnap him.  He was able to break free by running into a populated square in Baghdad.

“I thank God, because if they caught him, he was going to die,” Imaad said.

Omar, now 15, didn’t want to talk about it.

With father Imaad, the militia succeeded in its kidnapping attempts.  He spent several weeks in a prison, was beat with guns and “they did whatever they wanted to do to me,” he said.

Life wasn’t like this before 2003, when tension heated betwen the two groups following Sept. 11 attacks and democracy was introduced in Iraq, Imaad said.

“The Iraqi army was all Shiite and it is not good.  Here in America, you see white, black, Spanish people in the police and Army,” he said.

“We didn’t sleep for many years,” said 36-year-old Maysoon, Omar’s mom.

“So I left everything,” said Imaad, 43.

The family became refugees.  The Hasans—Maysoon, Imaad, and their children, Omar, Sarah, 14, and Hajer 10—left their home, a successful electronics business and family.  They arrived first in Syria, where Imaad spent two years working in a shoe store.  The family lived in a cheap apartment and it was a difficult two years, he said.  The kids missed one year of school.

In March 2008, they received clearance  from the United Nations to flee the Middle East and seek refuge in the United States.  The United States allows between 50,000 andc 70,000 refugees to enter the country every year.

On the plane ride to JFK Airport in New York, Imaad said he felt worried and nervous.

“It felt like a dark future for me,” Imaad said.  Once a respected business owner in Iraq, all he knew about America was what he had seen in John Wayne movies.

The Hasan family spent a week with a host family, then were placed in an apartment by World Relief Aurora.  The children received English lessons and both parents started working.  Imaad is now a machine operator and Maysoon is a cafeteria cashier at Jefferson Middle School in Aurora.

Through Bryan’s House [sic], a non-profit that helps refugees save and work their way out of poverty, the pair was able to save $12,000 toward the down payment on their first U.S. home on Aurora’s West Side.  That down payment was matched by various grant programs, according to Rick Guzman, co-founder of Bryan’s House [Read about Bryan House and Emmanuel House below].

“We are safe and very grateful,” said Imaad.  “We experienced not feeling safe for several years.  If you had to choose food or safety, you’d choose safety every time.”

Next year the family will apply for U.S. citizenship, although Maysoon said she missses her family dearly.

“When we first arrived here, we had this idea that we’d go back,” Imaad said.

But he isn’t sure it that place exists now.  Baghdad, an ancient city, is now “a garbage city,” Imaad said.

Now, they’ve rebuilt their lives here, Imaad said.  “We’ve grown roots.”

“Here, we have our freedom,” Omar said.

____________________
This article goes on to profile two other refugees: Sahr Kanjama from Sierra Leone, and Aloune Khotisene from Laos.

 Go to the Emmanuel House /Bryan House main page on this site.  Below, Lulay’s article as it looked in the paper on  July 3, 2011.  Go here for journalist/photographer Peter Hoffman’s portrait of Imaad.

Bryan House story by Stephanine Lulay featuring the Hasan family

 

Posted in Social Change | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Hear Us

Hear UsHear Us is a national organization whose mission is to bring voice and visibility to the homeless—especially homeless children and youth, and also their mothers.  Diane Nilan—who has spent a distinguished lifetime advocating for homeless people, starting or running shelters, and playing a major part in helping homeless children get the education they need— founded Hear Us in 2005.

More on the Hear Us main page

…where, among other things, you’ll find:

  • The Hear Us website
  • A Huffington Post article about Diane
  • A radio documentary on Diane
  • Thoughts about the PBS showing of her film on the edge—and more…

My wife, Linda Bonifas-Guzman, is on the Hear Us board of directors.  She and I volunteered at Hesed House (in Aurora, IL) when Diane ran it, and today still volunteer at Daybreak Shelter (Joliet, IL), which Diane started in the mid-80’s.  For us, it’s been around a 30-year adventure, “adventure” being a perfect word for anyone privileged to be involved with Diane and her mission.

I remember an afternoon around seven years ago when Diane called me up to announce that she was selling her town home and most everything she owned to buy and RV and travel around the country filming homelessness.  I must have been silent for a long time because the next thing I remember was her saying, “Richard, Richard, are you there?”  I think my first words were, “Do you have a movie camera?”  “No,” she said, “Do you know where I can get a good one cheap?”

Diane-Wander-Not-LostShe did buy the RV.  She did buy some movie equipment.  And now several documentaries later she travels the country coast-to-coast, a regular at Columbia University in New York, Duke University in North Carolina, and UCLA in California.  At the Hear Us website you can find out more about the films My Own Four Walls, on the edge, and The Littlest Nomads, among others.

Also find out about her book Crossing the Line: Taking Steps to End Homelessness.  I helped her with the book in 2004, and even sent a copy to my publisher at Loyola University Press.  He said he’d been very moved by the book, more so than many, many he’d read recently, but finally declined: a money decision, he said, feeling he wouldn’t be able to sell enough copies.  It was the best rejection letter I’d ever seen—and to this day I think he misjudged the book’s potential.  I wrote this about the book—a blurb which appears first in the book’s first printing:  “Read this book.  Diane Nilan has spent a distinguished lifetime helping the homeless.  She writes beautifully, from the heart, and will help you feel from your own heart not only the desperation of homeless persons but their particular strengths as well.  You might even start daring to hope that the plight of homelessness might someday be solved.”

 Return to the  SOCIAL CHANGE  main page.

Posted in Social Change | Tagged , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment