Elitism and Elections

The Atlantic is a magazine I think everyone should read, even though its analyses are often shot through with a kind of elitism it has often critiqued itself.  For example, the cover of one of its 2018 issues (at left) highlights its reporting on America’s growing aristocracy, which creates a “gilded future for the top 10 percent, and the loss of opportunity for everyone else.”  The January 2025 issue contains four essays on the 2024 election. They’re brilliant and need to be taken seriously.  But they also suffer from an elitism that clouds their reaction to some of the major reasons Donald Trump won, partly because of stunning gains among groups of people—the young, women, people of color—you wouldn’t have thought would vote Trump in such numbers.

George Packer’s “The End of Democratic Delusions” explores the Democrats’ misunderstanding of Identity Politics.  Just because you’re a person of color doesn’t mean you’ll always vote Democratic, etc.  Sophie Gilbert’s “The Gender War Is Here” focuses on—well, gender—though it struck me as somewhat schizophrenic, saying, on the one hand that this is going to happen to women, but that women don’t have to let these things happen to them.  It ends: “He won’t ruin women, but he will absolutely destroy a generation of men who take his vile messaging to heart.”  David Frum explores the new administration’s foreign policy, especially the threatened tariffs.  And Helen Lewis explores the Joe Rogan phenomenon, a testament to the power of new media and the continuing power of maleness.  I’d call it “patriarchy,” but part of my point here is to steer away, for a moment at least, from what many perceive to be “elitist language.”

These pieces all focused by and large on deep, underlying issues.  But in one of his many post-election interviews, Trump said, “I won this election because of one word: ‘groceries.’”  Not one of the Atlantic analyses mentioned groceries.  When, during the campaign, I got texts from James Carville asking for money to bolster the Harris-Walz campaign, I couldn’t help but think: Are you kidding? You invented the phrase, “It’s the economy, stupid!”  It’s groceries.

Not to say that groceries is less deep than misunderstanding identity politics.  Abraham Mazlow’s popular Self-Actualization Pyramid puts “Physiological Needs” and “Safety Needs” at the bottom of a pyramid which puts “Self-Actualization” needs at the very top.  Perhaps the pyramid should be turned on its head, or perhaps it shouldn’t be a pyramid at all but a circle. Elites tend to take Self-Actualization more seriously than groceries.  And they also tend to forget that Trump’s appeal in fact goes well beyond groceries: that abortion continues to divide the nation, that a kind of cultural trendiness has crept into LGBTQ issues that alarms many people (even in the LGBTQ community itself), that many of us rail against government inefficiency all the time. Etc.  The biggest disconnect in all this for me is that despite being so against the cultural elite, MAGA nation seems not to rail much against the economic elite, which so many of its members definitely are not part of.  The growing wealth gap in our nation is one of those deep things that needs attention.  That may be too much of an elitist concern for the moment, but it seems to me closer to groceries than self-actualization. It’s also true that it’s harder to draw a direct correlation between billionaires and groceries.

There’s also a fifth essay in the January 2025 issue appearing about one-third of the way through.  It has nothing directly to do with the election but might have been included by design anyway.  It’s Caitlin Flanagan’s lovely tribute to her parents and to the great Nobel Laureate Irish poet Seamus Heaney.  Its title comes from one of Heaney’s most famous lines: “Walk on air against your better judgment,” which is an invitation to hope even though hope itself seems to go against your better judgment.  She says Seamus Heaney “didn’t believe in a force as mere as optimism.  He believed in hope, “something far greater and more powerful.” She also quotes lines from his The Cure at Troy, which is a good way to end this commentary on the election as so many people on both sides of our stark divisions look out on what they believe is a terrible, almost apocalyptic, future.

So hope for a great sea-change
On this side of revenge.
Believe that a further shore

Is reachable from here.
Believe in miracles
And cures and healing wells.

Posted in Reviews & Commentary | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Subterranean Fun

Vana Liya’s shows remain flowing and gently strong, but they’re getting more fun, too, as witnessed in the VIDEO below of her October 2024 show at The Subterranean in Chicago, her second in the city this year.  The video captures 8-minutes of the fun, beginning with her signature song “Gold.” Everything moves along, probably as it has concert after concert, but when it comes time for Daniel and Derek (aka Man of the Forest) to do their neat solos in harmony, Daniel suddenly flips the guitar over his head and plays it upside down as it rests on his shoulders.

The first time I experienced this live was when I was in high school and directed the year’s talent show.  A band—Sato and the Mellotones, I think—were auditioning and were really good.  They were going to make it.  But halfway through their song the guitarist flips his guitar over his head, at which my assistant director, Phil Brooks, jumped up and shouted, “No! No! That cheapens your act!”  I didn’t agree, and neither did Sato, who said, stunned, almost pleading, “But he’s got to do that because next he picks it with his teeth.”

Well, Daniel stopped short of that, thankfully, but it was good to see him having fun on stage.  I think he’s a great guitarist, and I still point people to this YouTube Video of him playing “Way Down Low” at the Stork Club in Oakland, California, as a prime example of someone building a beautiful, improvised solo.  It’s brilliant.  And he’s played brilliantly for a long time, but early on he seemed shy, almost stepping out of the spotlight sometimes when he played.  Being in Vana Liya’s band has made him more of a showman, perhaps a secondary concern in music, but still a crucially important part of making live music spark.

Vana Liya and the band were second on the bill to KBong and Johnny Cosmic, and things really start sparking when KBong himself comes out to finish off Vana’s “Feeling Good.”  “It all started with him.”  She says something like that because it was KBong who took her on her first tour many years ago, and why, when she’s doing “Feeling Good” on the acoustic Sugar Shack Sessions, she says, “Shout out to my boy KBong.”  So behind the good fun there was a long history of togetherness, something that adds to the fun a deep joy.

Go HERE for more of Dan Guzman’s music, as well as music from others in our family.

Posted in Music & Meaning, Music & Media Podcasts | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

Awards: A Father’s Perspective

Below is an 8-minute VIDEO of Rick Guzman’s remarks after receiving one of his alma mater’s 2024 Alumni of the Year awards.  It was a stellar group, including a doctor, a widely published poet, and a 3-star general, which explains Rick’s first comment: “I’ve never followed a general before.”  His brief remarks beautifully combined several themes he has honed over the past few years when talking about The Neighbor Project, especially the ideas that you have to believe in your neighbors enough to invest in them, and you have to help them become the leaders and change makers they are inherently capable of becoming. The links below take you to other videos where these ideas are explained more fully.

Here I’d like to expand on another perspective, the one of a father watching his sons mature and become those change makers themselves.  My perspective is grounded in profound gratitude. When my youngest son Bryan died at the age of 21, my grief was mixed with an overwhelming sense of privilege.  How fortunate was I, I felt, to have had the luck of being this person’s father. I feel this way about each one of the boys.  Rick, Aaron, and Daniel followed me in speaking at Bryan’s memorial service, and afterwards, Hal Wilde, then president of North Central College, came up to me with tears in his eyes and said, “You’re the luckiest man in the room.”  I told him later that it was a moment I’ll never forget because for me it was a truth that touched the core of my being.

I believe parents take too much credit for the things their children do well, and also too much blame for things that don’t work out as well.  In the end, especially when it comes to their successes, it comes down to the fact that they were born with something outstanding in them. Of course, we play some role in nourishing and shaping that something, but finally it’s mainly them.  We’re just fortunate enough to be at their side as that something matures. Rick’s voice breaks slightly as he mentions me knowing how important it is to spend your life equipping someone to be the best leader they can be.  Doing that is one of the major themes of his career.  However, I never actually spoke to him directly about doing that.

My intellectual patron saint is James Baldwin, and it was Daniel who once reminded me of something Baldwin wrote: “Children may not listen to their parents, but they never fail to observe what they do.”  Many times I have talked directly to my sons about some big life issues and what they should and should not be doing, but it’s a simple truth bordering on cliché that they probably learn more by just watching you.  They learn both small things and the large important things in life.  Daniel once sent me a picture of his Christmas tree.  It showed him pointing to simple silver balls hanging near the trunk on the inside.  He wrote, “Brings out the inner glow,” just as he had heard me say and do when decorating our trees for years.  Aaron once told me he said to his daughter Grace, “I did this with my Dad, and you’ll do this too with your little one.” In church, on a Father’s Day, the pastor asked if anyone would like to say anything about their Father.  These moments sometimes backfire when nobody has anything to say, but Aaron spoke up right away, saying, “When I think of my Dad I think of all the time he spent with us, watching our sports and concerts, playing catch, taking us to Wrigley Field….”

My profound gratitude is also for these supposedly small times that really add up in the end. I can’t say that I enjoyed every single minute, but in retrospect that’s what I tell my sons and all parents to try to do.  Enjoy every minute: because one day you may be a bit bored watching your umpteenth baseball game, but the next moment—because time does seem to go that fast—you’ll be watching your child conduct an orchestra, play a concert, or make a speech like the one below.

The best introduction to The Neighbor Project’s vision—including the idea of believing in your neighbor enough to invest in them—is Rick’s short talk “Every Person’s God-Given Ability to Contribute.”  See Aaron conducting a beautiful piece, which features his daughter Grace.  And see Daniel in concert.

Posted in Family, Music & Media Podcasts | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment